Pl. see the below page from the Central Govt published data.link
Regular IT assessments done by Dept is yielding only 7 to 8% of total Gross Direct tax collected where as Adv. Tax, TDS and SA Tax is 92% i.e the voluntary compliance .
Is there not a strong case for abolishing Assts for atleast individuals who have good track record of say 10 continuous years and have limited scrutiny assessments only for Corporates/Companies with incentives for exemption from assessments if they remit Tax at least 15% more year on year.This will take care of tax buoyancy ratio and reduce assessment costs drastically.
Mr.Sunil Jain of FE recently sent a tweet to FM saying that IT dept is following up with him on some assessment notice despite complying with it and paying tax. Everyone of us have similar experiences on IT assessments despite computerisation. Straightaway all these scrutiny assessments can be called " IT Harassments "-no euphemism.
But it should also be emphasized that the scale of high pitched assessments has substantially come down over the last one/2 years but still more needs to be done in order to totally move away from Tax Terrorism to augment direct tax revenue. I am not making a case for tax evaders or dodgers who r small percentage and who will anyway continue to do so.
My firm conviction is ,if assessments are done away with , then more small businessmen will voluntarily pay under presumptive tax, file return and forget.Another indicator is the difference between how many assessees have paid tax/TDS and the no. who have filed returns.Almost 2 crore nos.!! Is it not sounding another loud bell for doing away with Assessments /Scrutiny assessments but with safeguards like good track record or yoy 15% inc. in tax remittance etc.
One last point. Out of such Tax assessed and shown collected by the Dept how much is contested in appeals before CITs, Tribunals , HCs and SCs.Huge burden on these Courts will also come down and unnecessary litigation is avoided. Lots of multiplier effects can be seen if assessments are abolished.
For encouraging people to file their Income Tax return, Govt can run a lottery or even give atleast health insurance policy under Ayushman Bharat free of cost.
Page 7 reproduced below:
Comments
Post a Comment