Thoughts on GST Council - Heightened Uncertainty & Black Swan Risks

Considering reciprocal tariff measures, now GOI is compelled to reduce Import duties.However domestic GST reductions are hanging fire for long esp on Health Insurance since Consumers do not have Bargaining power in the GST council to compel GST council to reduce the rates.

FM and GST Council will have to keep this in mind and slash the rates from 24% to 20% and 18% to 15% inorder to minimise the tax burden on the common man who has no clear representation in the GST Council .This will definitely boost consumption by putting more money in the hands of the people and will more than offset the revenue foregone. In times of Uncertainty, Kindly initiate steps to hear the Citizens' voice in GST Council. Is it not the Common Citizen who has an important stake as beneficiary of States' spending whereas FMs of the States have a mandate only to augment its resources to spend?Revenue side is represented whereas the beneficiary side remains unrepresented or under represented!

2)45 % GST+ TCS 1% on Cars is correct. This must definitely come down . If Personal Consumption is down, it is because of high GsT rates on top of the Inflation in the last few years , hampering discretionary income in the hands of aspirational middle class. GST council must take immediate cognisance of this .Central Govt must boldly undertake to compensate States at 8- 10% revenue growth for 5 yrs ,to push for GST rate reductions.

3)GOI is working on reduction in Fiscal deficit to 4.4% in FY25-26 and a Debt to GDP ratio of 56.1% as per Statement of Fiscal Policy under FRBM Act,2003,with a goal of reducing the Debt to GDP ratio to about 50%(approx) with an expected Nominal GDP growth rate of 10% to 11% over the next 5 years. While these Goals and Estimates are great what are the Black Swan events that can upset this calculation and so must provide for these risks.Therefore, GOI must have a cushion for a rise in FD and also an unexpected calamity that may push up Debt to GDP ratio.

4)The bigger question is -are the States aware of these Risks.They cannot wash off their hands by blaming the Centre.They have an equal responsibilty if not a higher responsibility on fiscal prudence.Why not SC take up freebies issue on suo motu basis and declare any further freebies must be linked to additional mobilisation of resources and not through borrowings.

See the Uncertainty Index of US to understand the increase in Uncertainty and Risks

Comments

Hanuman and Ganesha!

The two major loved deities of the Hindu pantheon are Hanuman and Ganesha. Let us dwell into the concepts and significance of these two dieties. Ganesha, the son of Parvati and Shiv, is worshipped first before starting any new job or work. Even if you want to start writing or reading , you invoke the blessings of Lord Ganesha who goes under various names- Ganapathi, Vigneshwar, Vinayak, and Pillayar in Tamilnadu. Ganesha Gayathri, Pancharatnam are some of the important Ganesha mantras and hymns. Adi Ganesha idol is in a Temple near Tiruvarur in Tamilnadu with a human face.The mythological story says that Shiv slew His head and then fixed the head of the animal that He saw first after this beheading of His son. Ganesha after that with the elephant head is worshipped as the wisdom god by Hindus. Why only Hindus. He is worshipped in Indonesia where He finds Himself in their currency notes. He is considered the destroyer of evil in Japan. In Mexico, Ganesha idols were said to h...

Shrinking middle class in India?-Data show Growing Middle class!

Key Findings from the SBI Eco wrap Report(25th Oct 2024) Income Inequality is Decreasing : The report uses the Gini coefficient to demonstrate a decline in income inequality in India. The shift is most noticeable in lower income brackets, with a substantial portion moving into higher income groups. This aligns with a rightward shift in the income distribution curve. ITR Filings are Increasing : The number of ITR filings has significantly increased, indicating a growing tax base. This growth is particularly evident in previously untapped states (Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, etc.), suggesting broader economic participation.Below is the chart which shows No. of tax payers in Different income Group in AY2014 and AY2024 which clearly shows that the bulk have moved up from Rs.1.5lac to Rs5 lac to Rs.2.5 lac to Rs.10 lac(highlighted in yellow colour) Growth in 'Crorepati' Taxpayers : The number of taxpayers earning over ₹1 crore has increased significantly, highlighting the expansi...

State of the Indian Economy: Navigating Global Uncertainties

The global economic landscape is rapidly evolving, with trade policy uncertainty emerging as the key driver of the near-term outlook. Recent US tariff announcements have stoked fears of a global trade war, with countries still working out their appropriate responses in this uncertain environment. Despite these external headwinds, the Indian economy has exhibited marked resilience. Although the weakening global economic outlook could impact overall growth through weaker external demand, India's domestic growth engines - consumption and investment - are relatively less susceptible to external pressures. Prospects for the farm sector have been boosted by the forecast of an above normal southwest monsoon for 2025, which could augment farm incomes and keep food prices under check. Headline inflation moderated to a 67-month low of 3.3% in March, mainly due to moderation in food prices. Global Economic Outlook: Trade Tensions and Market Volatility The global economic landscape is facing ...

We are what we are !!

Search This Blog